Statement List for Metamath Proof Explorer - 3101-3200 - Page 32 of 58
| Type | Label | Description |
| Statement |
| |
| Syntax | coa 3101 |
Extend the definition of a class to include the ordinal addition
operation.
|
| class
+o |
| |
| Syntax | comu 3102 |
Extend the definition of a class to include the ordinal multiplication
operation.
|
| class
·o |
| |
| Syntax | coe 3103 |
Extend the definition of a class to include the ordinal exponentiation
operation.
|
| class
↑o |
| |
| Definition | df-1o 3104 |
Define the ordinal number 1.
|
| ⊢
1o = suc ∅ |
| |
| Definition | df-2o 3105 |
Define the ordinal number 2.
|
| ⊢
2o = suc 1o |
| |
| Definition | df-oadd 3106 |
Define the ordinal addition operation.
|
| ⊢
+o = {〈〈x,
y〉, z〉∣((x ∈ On ∧ y ∈ On) ∧ z = (rec({〈w, v〉∣v
= suc w}, x) ‘y))} |
| |
| Definition | df-omul 3107 |
Define the ordinal multiplication operation.
|
| ⊢
·o = {〈〈x, y〉,
z〉∣((x ∈ On ∧ y ∈ On) ∧ z = (rec({〈w, v〉∣v
= (w +o x)}, ∅) ‘y))} |
| |
| Definition | df-oexp 3108 |
Define the ordinal exponentiation operation.
|
| ⊢
↑o = {〈〈x, y〉,
z〉∣((x ∈ On ∧ y ∈ On) ∧ z = if(x =
∅, (1o ∖ y),
(rec({〈w, v〉∣v
= (w ·o x)}, 1o) ‘y)))} |
| |
| Theorem | 1o 3109 |
Ordinal 1 is an ordinal number.
|
| ⊢
1o ∈ On |
| |
| Theorem | 2o 3110 |
Ordinal 2 is an ordinal number.
|
| ⊢
2o ∈ On |
| |
| Theorem | df1o2 3111 |
Expanded value of the ordinal number 1.
|
| ⊢
1o = {∅} |
| |
| Theorem | df2o2 3112 |
Expanded value of the ordinal number 2.
|
| ⊢
2o = {∅, {∅}} |
| |
| Theorem | 0ne1oOLD 3113 |
Ordinal zero is not equal to ordinal one.
|
| ⊢
¬ ∅ = 1o |
| |
| Theorem | ordgt0ge1 3114 |
Two ways of expressing that an ordinal class is positive.
|
| ⊢
(Ord A → (∅ ∈
A ↔ 1o ⊆
A)) |
| |
| Theorem | el1o 3115 |
Membership in ordinal one.
|
| ⊢
(A ∈ 1o
↔ A = ∅) |
| |
| Theorem | 0lt1o 3116 |
Ordinal zero is less than ordinal one.
|
| ⊢
∅ ∈ 1o |
| |
| Theorem | fnoa 3117 |
Functionality and domain of ordinal addition.
|
| ⊢
+o Fn (On × On) |
| |
| Theorem | fnom 3118 |
Functionality and domain of ordinal multiplication.
|
| ⊢
·o Fn (On × On) |
| |
| Theorem | oav 3119 |
Value of ordinal addition.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On) → (A +o B) = (rec({〈x, y〉∣y
= suc x}, A) ‘B)) |
| |
| Theorem | omv 3120 |
Value of ordinal multiplication.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On) → (A ·o B) = (rec({〈x, y〉∣y
= (x +o A)}, ∅) ‘B)) |
| |
| Theorem | oe0lem 3121 |
A helper lemma for oe0 3130 and others.
|
| ⊢
((φ ∧ A = ∅) → ψ)
& ⊢ (((A ∈ On ∧ φ) ∧ ∅ ∈ A) → ψ)
⇒ ⊢ ((A ∈ On ∧ φ) → ψ) |
| |
| Theorem | oev 3122 |
Value of ordinal exponentiation.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On) → (A ↑o B) = if(A =
∅, (1o ∖ B),
(rec({〈x, y〉∣y
= (x ·o A)}, 1o) ‘B))) |
| |
| Theorem | oevn0 3123 |
Value of ordinal exponentiation at a nonzero mantissa.
|
| ⊢
(((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On) ∧ ∅ ∈ A) → (A
↑o B) =
(rec({〈x, y〉∣y
= (x ·o A)}, 1o) ‘B)) |
| |
| Theorem | oa0 3124 |
Addition with zero. Proposition 8.3 of [TakeutiZaring] p. 57.
|
| ⊢
(A ∈ On → (A +o ∅) = A) |
| |
| Theorem | om0 3125 |
Ordinal multiplication with zero. Definition 8.15 of [TakeutiZaring]
p. 62.
|
| ⊢
(A ∈ On → (A ·o ∅) =
∅) |
| |
| Theorem | om0x 3126 |
Ordinal multiplication with zero. Definition 8.15 of [TakeutiZaring]
p. 62. Unlike om0 3125, this version works whether or not A is
an ordinal. However it since it is an artifact of our particular
function value definition outside the domain, we will not use it
in order to be conventional and present it only as a curiosity.
|
| ⊢
(A ·o
∅) = ∅ |
| |
| Theorem | oe0m 3127 |
Ordinal exponentiation with zero mantissa.
|
| ⊢
(A ∈ On → (∅
↑o A) =
(1o ∖ A)) |
| |
| Theorem | oe0m0 3128 |
Ordinal exponentiation with zero mantissa and zero exponent.
Proposition 8.31 of [TakeutiZaring] p. 67.
|
| ⊢
(∅ ↑o ∅) =
1o |
| |
| Theorem | oe0m1 3129 |
Ordinal exponentiation with zero mantissa and nonzero exponent.
Proposition 8.31(2) of [TakeutiZaring] p. 67.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ ∅ ∈
A) → (∅
↑o A) =
∅) |
| |
| Theorem | oe0 3130 |
Ordinal exponentiation with zero exponent. Definition 8.30 of
[TakeutiZaring] p. 67.
|
| ⊢
(A ∈ On → (A ↑o ∅) =
1o) |
| |
| Theorem | oasuc 3131 |
Addition with successor. Definition 8.1 of [TakeutiZaring] p. 56.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On) → (A +o suc B) = suc (A
+o B)) |
| |
| Theorem | oa1suc 3132 |
Addition with 1 is same as successor. Proposition 4.34(a) of [Mendelson]
p. 266.
|
| ⊢
(A ∈ On → (A +o 1o) = suc
A) |
| |
| Theorem | omsuc 3133 |
Multiplication with successor. Definition 8.15 of [TakeutiZaring]
p. 62.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On) → (A ·o suc B) = ((A
·o B)
+o A)) |
| |
| Theorem | oesuc 3134 |
Ordinal exponentiation with a successor exponent. Definition 8.30 of
[TakeutiZaring] p. 67.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On) → (A ↑o suc B) = ((A
↑o B)
·o A)) |
| |
| Theorem | oalim 3135 |
Ordinal addition with a limit ordinal. Definition 8.1 of
[TakeutiZaring] p. 56.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ (B ∈ C
∧ Lim B)) → (A +o B) = ∪x ∈ B
(A +o x)) |
| |
| Theorem | omlim 3136 |
Ordinal multiplication with a limit ordinal. Definition 8.15 of
[TakeutiZaring] p. 62.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ (B ∈ C
∧ Lim B)) → (A ·o B) = ∪x ∈ B
(A ·o x)) |
| |
| Theorem | oelim 3137 |
Ordinal exponentiation with a limit exponent and nonzero mantissa.
Definition 8.30 of [TakeutiZaring] p. 67.
|
| ⊢
(((A ∈ On ∧ (B ∈ C
∧ Lim B)) ∧ ∅ ∈
A) → (A ↑o B) = ∪x ∈ B
(A ↑o x)) |
| |
| Theorem | oacl 3138 |
Closure law for ordinal addition. Proposition 8.2 of [TakeutiZaring]
p. 57.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On) → (A +o B) ∈ On) |
| |
| Theorem | omcl 3139 |
Closure law for ordinal multiplication. Proposition 8.16 of
[TakeutiZaring] p. 57.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On) → (A ·o B) ∈ On) |
| |
| Theorem | oecl 3140 |
Closure law for ordinal exponentiation.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On) → (A ↑o B) ∈ On) |
| |
| Theorem | oa0r 3141 |
Ordinal addition with zero. Proposition 8.3 of [TakeutiZaring]
p. 57.
|
| ⊢
(A ∈ On → (∅
+o A) = A) |
| |
| Theorem | om0r 3142 |
Ordinal multiplication with zero. Proposition 8.18(1) of
[TakeutiZaring] p. 63.
|
| ⊢
(A ∈ On → (∅
·o A) =
∅) |
| |
| Theorem | o1p1e2 3143 |
1 + 1 = 2 for ordinal numbers.
|
| ⊢
(1o +o 1o) =
2o |
| |
| Theorem | om1 3144 |
Ordinal multiplication with 1. Proposition 8.18(2) of [TakeutiZaring]
p. 63.
|
| ⊢
(A ∈ On → (A ·o 1o)
= A) |
| |
| Theorem | om1r 3145 |
Ordinal multiplication with 1. Proposition 8.18(2) of [TakeutiZaring]
p. 63.
|
| ⊢
(A ∈ On →
(1o ·o A) = A) |
| |
| Theorem | oe1 3146 |
Ordinal exponentiation with an exponent of 1.
|
| ⊢
(A ∈ On → (A ↑o 1o) =
A) |
| |
| Theorem | oe1m 3147 |
Ordinal exponentiation with a mantissa of 1. Proposition 8.31(3) of
[TakeutiZaring] p. 67.
|
| ⊢
(A ∈ On →
(1o ↑o A) = 1o) |
| |
| Theorem | oaordi 3148 |
Ordering property of ordinal addition. Proposition 8.4 of
[TakeutiZaring] p. 58.
|
| ⊢
((B ∈ On ∧ C ∈ On) → (A ∈ B
→ (C +o A) ∈ (C
+o B))) |
| |
| Theorem | oaord 3149 |
Ordering property of ordinal addition. Proposition 8.4 of [TakeutiZaring]
p. 58 and its converse.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On ∧ C ∈ On) → (A ∈ B
↔ (C +o A) ∈ (C
+o B))) |
| |
| Theorem | oacan 3150 |
Left cancellation law for ordinal addition. Corollary 8.5 of
[TakeutiZaring] p. 58.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On ∧ C ∈ On) → ((A +o B) = (A
+o C) ↔ B = C)) |
| |
| Theorem | oaword 3151 |
Weak ordering property of ordinal addition.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On ∧ C ∈ On) → (A ⊆ B
↔ (C +o A) ⊆ (C
+o B))) |
| |
| Theorem | oawordri 3152 |
Weak ordering property of ordinal addition. Proposition 8.7 of
[TakeutiZaring] p. 59.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On ∧ C ∈ On) → (A ⊆ B
→ (A +o C) ⊆ (B
+o C))) |
| |
| Theorem | oaord1 3153 |
An ordinal is less than its sum with a non-zero ordinal. Theorem 18 of
[Suppes] p. 209 and its converse.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On) → (∅ ∈ B ↔ A
∈ (A +o B))) |
| |
| Theorem | oaword1 3154 |
An ordinal is less than or equal to its sum with another. Part of
Exercise 5 of [TakeutiZaring] p.
62. (For the other part see
oaord1 3153.)
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On) → A ⊆ (A
+o B)) |
| |
| Theorem | oaword2 3155 |
An ordinal is less than or equal to its sum with another. Theorem 21 of
[Suppes] p. 209.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On) → A ⊆ (B
+o A)) |
| |
| Theorem | oawordeulem 3156 |
Lemma for oawordex 3159.
|
| ⊢
A ∈ On
& ⊢ B ∈ On
& ⊢ S = {y ∈
On∣B ⊆ (A +o y)}
⇒ ⊢ (A ⊆ B
→ ∃!x ∈ On (A +o x) = B) |
| |
| Theorem | oawordeu 3157 |
Existence theorem for weak ordering of ordinal sum. Proposition 8.8 of
[TakeutiZaring] p. 59.
|
| ⊢
(((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On) ∧ A ⊆ B)
→ ∃!x ∈ On (A +o x) = B) |
| |
| Theorem | oawordexr 3158 |
Existence theorem for weak ordering of ordinal sum.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ ∃x ∈ On (A
+o x) = B) → A
⊆ B) |
| |
| Theorem | oawordex 3159 |
Existence theorem for weak ordering of ordinal sum. Proposition 8.8 of
[TakeutiZaring] p. 59 and its
converse. See oawordeu 3157 for
uniqueness.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On) → (A ⊆ B
↔ ∃x ∈ On (A +o x) = B)) |
| |
| Theorem | oaordex 3160 |
Existence theorem for ordering of ordinal sum. Similar to Proposition
4.34(f) of [Mendelson] p. 266 and its
converse.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On) → (A ∈ B
↔ ∃x ∈ On (∅ ∈
x ∧ (A +o x) = B))) |
| |
| Theorem | oa00 3161 |
An ordinal sum is zero iff both of its arguments are zero.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On) → ((A +o B) = ∅ ↔ (A = ∅ ∧ B = ∅))) |
| |
| Theorem | oalimcl 3162 |
The ordinal sum with a limit ordinal is a limit ordinal. Proposition
8.11 of [TakeutiZaring] p. 60.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ (B ∈ C
∧ Lim B)) → Lim (A +o B)) |
| |
| Theorem | oaass 3163 |
Ordinal addition is associative. Theorem 25 of [Suppes] p. 211.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On ∧ C ∈ On) → ((A +o B) +o C) = (A
+o (B
+o C))) |
| |
| Theorem | omordi 3164 |
Ordering property of ordinal multiplication. Half of Proposition 8.19
of [TakeutiZaring] p. 63.
|
| ⊢
(((B ∈ On ∧ C ∈ On) ∧ ∅ ∈ C) → (A
∈ B → (C ·o A) ∈ (C
·o B))) |
| |
| Theorem | oen0 3165 |
Ordinal exponentiation with a nonzero mantissa is nonzero. Proposition
8.32 of [TakeutiZaring] p. 67.
|
| ⊢
(((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On) ∧ ∅ ∈ A) → ∅ ∈ (A ↑o B)) |
| |
| Theorem | nna0 3166 |
Addition with zero. Theorem 4I(A1) of [Enderton] p. 79.
|
| ⊢
(A ∈ ω → (A +o ∅) = A) |
| |
| Theorem | nnm0 3167 |
Multiplication with zero. Theorem 4J(A1) of [Enderton] p. 80.
|
| ⊢
(A ∈ ω → (A ·o ∅) =
∅) |
| |
| Theorem | nnasuc 3168 |
Addition with successor. Theorem 4I(A2) of [Enderton] p. 79.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω) → (A +o suc B) = suc (A
+o B)) |
| |
| Theorem | nnmsuc 3169 |
Multiplication with successor. Theorem 4J(A2) of [Enderton] p. 80.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω) → (A ·o suc B) = ((A
·o B)
+o A)) |
| |
| Theorem | nna0r 3170 |
Addition to zero. Remark in proof of Theorem 4K(2) of [Enderton]
p. 81.
|
| ⊢
(A ∈ ω → (∅
+o A) = A) |
| |
| Theorem | nnm0r 3171 |
Multiplication with zero. Exercise 16 of [Enderton] p. 82.
|
| ⊢
(A ∈ ω → (∅
·o A) =
∅) |
| |
| Theorem | nnacl 3172 |
Closure of addition of natural numbers. Proposition 8.9 of
[TakeutiZaring] p. 59.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω) → (A +o B) ∈ ω) |
| |
| Theorem | nnmcl 3173 |
Closure of multiplication of natural numbers. Proposition 8.17 of
[TakeutiZaring] p. 63.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω) → (A ·o B) ∈ ω) |
| |
| Theorem | nnarcl 3174 |
Reverse closure law for addition of natural numbers. Exercise 1 of
[TakeutiZaring] p. 62 and its
converse.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ On ∧ B ∈ On) → ((A +o B) ∈ ω ↔ (A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω))) |
| |
| Theorem | nnacom 3175 |
Addition of natural numbers is commutative. Theorem 4K(2) of
[Enderton] p. 81.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω) → (A +o B) = (B
+o A)) |
| |
| Theorem | nnaordi 3176 |
Ordering property of addition. Proposition 8.4 of [TakeutiZaring]
p. 58, limited to natural numbers.
|
| ⊢
((B ∈ ω ∧ C ∈ ω) → (A ∈ B
→ (C +o A) ∈ (C
+o B))) |
| |
| Theorem | nnaord 3177 |
Ordering property of addition. Proposition 8.4 of [TakeutiZaring]
p. 58, limited to natural numbers, and its converse.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω ∧ C ∈ ω) → (A ∈ B
↔ (C +o A) ∈ (C
+o B))) |
| |
| Theorem | nnaordr 3178 |
Ordering property of addition of natural numbers.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω ∧ C ∈ ω) → (A ∈ B
↔ (A +o C) ∈ (B
+o C))) |
| |
| Theorem | nnaass 3179 |
Addition of natural numbers is associative. (This can be extended to
all ordinals with a longer proof.) Theorem 4K(1) of [Enderton]
p. 81.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω ∧ C ∈ ω) → ((A +o B) +o C) = (A
+o (B
+o C))) |
| |
| Theorem | nndi 3180 |
Distributive law for natural numbers. (This can be extended to
all ordinals with a longer proof.) Theorem 4K(3) of [Enderton]
p. 81.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω ∧ C ∈ ω) → (A ·o (B +o C)) = ((A
·o B)
+o (A
·o C))) |
| |
| Theorem | nnmass 3181 |
Multiplication of natural numbers is associative. (This can be extended
to all ordinals with a longer proof.) Theorem 4K(4) of [Enderton]
p. 81.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω ∧ C ∈ ω) → ((A ·o B) ·o C) = (A
·o (B
·o C))) |
| |
| Theorem | nnmsucr 3182 |
Multiplication with successor. Exercise 16 of [Enderton] p. 82.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω) → (suc A ·o B) = ((A
·o B)
+o B)) |
| |
| Theorem | nnmcom 3183 |
Multiplication of natural numbers is commutative. Theorem 4K(5) of
[Enderton] p. 81.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω) → (A ·o B) = (B
·o A)) |
| |
| Theorem | nnacan 3184 |
Cancellation law for addition of natural numbers.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω ∧ C ∈ ω) → ((A +o B) = (A
+o C) ↔ B = C)) |
| |
| Theorem | nnaword 3185 |
Weak ordering property of addition.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω ∧ C ∈ ω) → (A ⊆ B
↔ (C +o A) ⊆ (C
+o B))) |
| |
| Theorem | nnaword1 3186 |
Weak ordering property of addition.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω) → A ⊆ (A
+o B)) |
| |
| Theorem | nnaword2 3187 |
Weak ordering property of addition.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω) → A ⊆ (B
+o A)) |
| |
| Theorem | nnmordi 3188 |
Ordering property of multiplication. Half of Proposition 8.19 of
[TakeutiZaring] p. 63, limited to
natural numbers.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω ∧ C ∈ ω) → ((A ∈ B
∧ ∅ ∈ C) → (C ·o A) ∈ (C
·o B))) |
| |
| Theorem | nnmord 3189 |
Ordering property of multiplication. Proposition 8.19 of
[TakeutiZaring] p. 63, limited to
natural numbers.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω ∧ C ∈ ω) → ((A ∈ B
∧ ∅ ∈ C) ↔ (C ·o A) ∈ (C
·o B))) |
| |
| Theorem | nnmcan 3190 |
Cancellation law for multiplication of natural numbers.
|
| ⊢
(((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω ∧ C ∈ ω) ∧ ∅ ∈ A) → ((A
·o B) = (A ·o C) ↔ B =
C)) |
| |
| Theorem | nnaordex 3191 |
Equivalence for ordering. Compare Exercise 23 of [Enderton] p. 88.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω) → (A ∈ B
↔ ∃x ∈ ω (∅
∈ x ∧ (A +o x) = B))) |
| |
| Theorem | nnawordex 3192 |
Equivalence for weak ordering of natural numbers.
|
| ⊢
((A ∈ ω ∧ B ∈ ω) → (A ⊆ B
↔ ∃x ∈ ω (A +o x) = B)) |
| |
| Theorem | 1onn 3193 |
One is a natural number.
|
| ⊢
1o ∈ ω |
| |
| Theorem | 2onn 3194 |
The ordinal 2 is a natural number.
|
| ⊢
2o ∈ ω |
| |
| Theorem | omsmolem 3195 |
Lemma for omsmo 3196.
|
| ⊢
(y ∈ ω →
(((A ⊆ On ∧ F:ω–→A) ∧ ∀x ∈ ω (F ‘x)
∈ (F ‘suc x)) → (z
∈ y → (F ‘z)
∈ (F ‘y)))) |
| |
| Theorem | omsmo 3196 |
A strictly monotonic ordinal function on the set of natural numbers
is one-to-one.
|
| ⊢
(((A ⊆ On ∧ F:ω–→A) ∧ ∀x ∈ ω (F ‘x)
∈ (F ‘suc x)) → F:ω–1-1→A) |
| |
| Syntax | wer 3197 |
Extend the definition of a wff to include the equivalence predicate.
|
| wff Er
R |
| |
| Syntax | cec 3198 |
Extend the definition of a class to include equivalence class.
|
| class
[A]R |
| |
| Syntax | cqs 3199 |
Extend the definition of a class to include quotient set.
|
| class
(A / R) |
| |
| Definition | df-er 3200 |
Define the equivalence predicate. R need
not be a relation but
ordinarily will be, in which case we call it an equivalence relation.
Our notation is not standard. A formal notation doesn't seem to exist
in the literature; instead only informal English tends to be used. Some
definitions in the literature may also require that R be a relation.
The present definition, although somewhat cryptic, nicely avoids dummy
variables. In er2 3201 we derive a more typical definition. We show
that
an equivalence relation is reflexive, symmetric, and transitive in
erref 3212, ersymb 3210, and ertr 3211.
|
| ⊢
(Er R ↔ (◡R ∪
(R ∘ R)) ⊆ R) |